21 - Adele
Suck It and See - Arctic Monkeys
Noel Gallagher's High Flying Birds -
|
|
Best Album of 2011 Finale
Last week I asked what you all thought was the best album of 2011 was, and we have a threeway tie:
a) 21 - Adele (Metacritic: 76/100, 7.8/10)
b) Suck It and See - Arctic Monkeys (Metacritic: 74/100, 8.0/10)
c) Noel Gallagher's High Flying Birds - Noel Gallagher's High Flying Birds (Metacritic: 69/100, 8.0/10)
So what of the albums above is your favourite?
B)
All 3 are highly overrated.
Wrong, infact 2 of the 3 are hugely UNDERRATED.Originally Posted by WilbertoSilva
Wrong? **** off.
Anyone heard of respecting opinions? These three got more votes than the others for a reason. I'm not asking people to agree with eachother just start realising that your opinions are not right or wrong. Seriously. It's just a bit of fun anyway.
Well, yeah, I agree with that. It was obviously just my opinion all are overrated, but I was told I was 'wrong' as if it was fact.
None. Especially not B.
...okay then. Why post that comment if you're insinuating not going to vote?
"I just want to make my point clear in saying that I shall not vote in this poll. Good day."
I dunno sometimes...
They're all ****, but B is the worst.
^^
Music should be listened to not rated.
If no one rated music you could argue no one would be able to suggest others to listen to their favourite bands.
But yeah, it can go overboard.
(c)
Doesn't sound like you'd like this site then.
Agree
Noel Gallagher's without doubt. Quality album!
All good albums, except B.
Noel Gallaghers High flying Birds is quality
True.
Sorry. This post marks the end of my contribution to this thread....okay then. Why post that comment if you're insinuating not going to vote?
"I just want to make my point clear in saying that I shall not vote in this poll. Good day."
I dunno sometimes...
I'll go for D - PJ Harvey
The only artist to win two Mercury awards with her 2011 release
Noel Gallagher
If I had a gun I'd shoot it at the sun, here's Noel coming up with another set of great lyrics with his manageress and producer, genius at work:
http://youtu.be/4Hw9xRcaQBE
Oasis>>>>RadioHeadI'll go for D - PJ Harvey
The only artist to win two Mercury awards with her 2011 release
Noel Gallagher
If I had a gun I'd shoot it at the sun, here's Noel coming up with another set of great lyrics with his manageress and producer, genius at work:
http://youtu.be/4Hw9xRcaQBE
AmyWinehouse>>>>PJ Harvey
FYI.
Close.
Radiohead > Oasis > Winehouse > PJ Harvey
B
Can't stand Noel Gallagher, his winey voice, or his winey high flying birds.
Adele's alright I guess.
Oasis > Winehouse > PJ Harvey > > > > > > Radiohead
Strange one for me, why not mate, was you never a fan of oasis then?
1. Wild Beasts - Smother
2. Wilco - The Whole Love
3. St Vincent - Strange Mercy
4. Fleet Foxes - Helplessness Blues
5. Bon Iver - Bon Iver
6. Girls - Father, Son, The Holy Ghost
7. PJ Harvey - Let England Shake
8. Okkervil River - I Am Very Far
9. Laura Marling - Creature I Don't Know
10. Beirut - The Rip Tide
AmyWinehouse>>>>>>PJ Harvey! Madness
PJ has a piles of recognised work, some fabulous material over the years and only gets better.
Winehouse, produced a tiny bit of work and I don't think she plans to release anything again....
AmyWinehouse>>>>>>PJ Harvey! Madness
PJ has a piles of recognised work, some fabulous material over the years and only gets better.
Winehouse, produced a tiny bit of work and I don't think she plans to release anything again....
PJ is a far superior artist than Whinehouse in my opinion. Whinehouse had one really amazing album, but PJ has had several amazing ones
| « Previous Thread | Next Thread » |
